Companies such as Amazon and Apple must take more responsibility to help collect, recycle and repair products which are contributing to 155,000 tonnes of waste electricals ending up in UK household bins every year, MPs argue.
The Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) has today (26 November) published its report on Electronic Waste and the Circular Economy, having found that the UK is lagging behind other nations in embedding a circular economy of use, reuse and recycle for small electronics, which has vital role in protecting the environment.
The manufacturing of new electronics from raw materials can cause huge human and environmental damage and releases significant carbon emissions, whilst electronic waste, when not properly treated, releases toxic chemicals that damage human and animal health.
The concept of use, reuse and recycle is well understood among bricks and mortar retailers which collect old electronics. But for all their protestations of claimed sustainability, major online retailers and marketplaces such as Amazon have so far avoided playing their part in the circular economy by not collecting or recycling electronics in the way other organisations have to.
Given the astronomical growth in sales by online vendors, particularly this year during the coronavirus pandemic, the EAC calls for online marketplaces to collect products and pay for their recycling to create a level playing field with physical retailers and producers that are not selling on their platforms.
It is not just online marketplaces failing to take responsibility for the environmental impact of electronics.
Tech companies such as Apple have been found to glue and solder together internal components making any repair nearly impossible. The EAC found that consumers do not have control over the products they own; they cannot take components out to repair themselves and they cannot access manuals on how issues can be fixed. Instead the charges proposed for repair by Apple in particular can be so expensive it is more economical to replace the item completely.
The committee recommends that the Government should enshrine the right to repair in law, and reduce VAT on repair services, as is the case in many EU countries. This could be an important incentive to boost a repair culture across the UK.
Repairing and recycling must become commonplace for electronics. In our report today, we have set out how the Government can achieve a circular economy for electronics – from VAT changes making repair more attractive, to the onus being placed on online marketplaces when delivering new product to collect old items they are replacing.
Addressing unnecessary electronic waste and making products built to last can also help ensure future supply of precious metals.
The availability of precious metals such as gold, tungsten, lithium and cobalt – often found in small electronics – are vital to the low-carbon economy as they are needed in wind turbines, solar panels and car batteries. The global supply of these materials will run out, and exporting, incinerating or sending old electronics to landfill could mean they are lost forever. The Government should therefore invest in high quality recycling methods that can retrieve these materials.
Rt Hon Philip Dunne MP, Environmental Audit Committee Chairman, said: “For too long companies like Amazon and Apple have been dodging their environmental responsibilities for the products they sell.
“Too many devices sold and made by these companies have a limited, and sometimes decreasing, lifespan and end up in bins, eventually going to landfill or incineration. There is no chance of precious metals being retrieved, which could quickly become a huge problem as the rare and disappearing materials are crucial for renewable energy such as wind turbines, solar panels and electric car batteries.
“Repairing and recycling must become commonplace for electronics. In our report today, we have set out how the Government can achieve a circular economy for electronics – from VAT changes making repair more attractive, to the onus being placed on online marketplaces when delivering new product to collect old items they are replacing.
“We cannot as a society continue to ignore the e-waste problem like so many of us have done for years – I plead guilty to keeping old mobile phones and chargers stuck at the back of the desk drawer gathering dust. We must take action if we are to protect the environment for years to come. I am going to change my behaviour. This report calls on us all to change too.”
[UPDATE 27 Nov]
An Amazon spokesperson told Circular Online: “Amazon is committed to minimising waste and helping our customers to reuse, repair, and recycle their products, and we provide a range of options that anyone can easily access through the Amazon Second Chance website.
“We have supported the recycling of more than 10,000 tonnes of electronic waste in the UK over the last decade. To address the root cause of eWaste, Amazon’s own devices are designed to last so that customers don’t have to upgrade every year, and we provide a range options such as Trade-In, Pre-Owned Devices, and recycling.
“Our latest generation of devices are made with more recycled materials than ever before, and we’re the first company to invest in renewable energy projects to address the energy used by our customers’ devices after purchase.
We remain steadfast in meeting The Climate Pledge—our commitment to reach net zero carbon by 2040, and we will continue to work constructively with Defra and others on the role of online marketplaces and the circular economy, and the challenges of electronic waste.”
