Swansea’s EfW Planning Refusal “Major Error In Judgement”

Swansea council’s planning committee’s refusal to grant planning permission for an energy-from-waste (EfW) plant ‘major error in judgment”, says stakeholder engagement specialist.

The Biffa EfW plant, planned for a business park at Llansamlet, would process 21,000 tonnes of non-hazardous waste that would otherwise go to landfill in Merthyr Tydfil.

Planning officers had recommended approval, saying there was no significant impact on residents, however the plant received local opposition, with more than 2,500 letters sent to the council urging it to refuse permission amid air-quality concerns.

Lee Petts – “Given that the Welsh government has only recently declared a climate emergency, this is no time to be ruling-out the generation of energy from residual waste in favour of continuing to send it to landfill some thirty miles away,”

BBC News reported that Extinction Rebellion activists staged a protest against the EfW plans outside a Biffa premise yesterday(7 May) morning, and that the decision by the council to refuse the proposal was unanimous.

Managing director of 52M Consulting and stakeholder engagement specialistLee Petts, said the council’s decision to refuse planning permission was a “major error in judgement.”

“Given that the Welsh government has only recently declared a climate emergency, this is no time to be ruling-out the generation of energy from residual waste in favour of continuing to send it to landfill some thirty miles away,” he said.

“Not only will trucking waste to Merthyr Tidfil create avoidable transport pollution, landfill is responsible for methane emissions that can be hard to contain and capture, and instead are released into the atmosphere. The short-term global warming potential of methane is higher than that of the CO2 that would be released by the proposed incinerator. 

“There is a strong environmental case for burning waste that can’t be recycled and extracting its latent energy content, helping to displace fossil fuels in electricity generation – it’s why so many countries that we regard as ‘green exemplars’ make such widespread use of waste-to-energy incineration. 

“The decision by Swansea city councillors to refuse planning permission in this instance amounts to a failure of common sense.”

Swansea council has been contacted for comment. 

Privacy Overview
Circular Online

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is temporarily stored in your browser and helps our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

More information about our Cookie Policy

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly necessary cookies allow core website functionality and the website cannot be used properly without them. These cookies include session cookies and persistent cookies.

Session cookies keep track of your current visit and how you navigate the site. They only last for the duration of your visit and are deleted from your device when you close your browser.

Persistent cookies last after you’ve closed your Internet browser and enable our website to recognise you as a repeat visitor and remember your actions and preferences when you return.

Functional cookies

Third party cookies include performance cookies and targeting cookies.

Performance cookies collect information about how you use a website, e.g. which pages you go to most often, and if you get error messages from web pages. These cookies don’t collect information that identifies you personally as a visitor, although they might collect the IP address of the device you use to access the site.

Targeting cookies collect information about your browsing habits. They are usually placed by advertising networks such as Google. The cookies remember that you have visited a website and this information is shared with other organisations such as media publishers.

Keeping these cookies enabled helps us to improve our website and display content that is more relevant to you and your interests across the Google content network.

Send this to a friend